Thursday 20 November 08 - 10:02
 

Insight & Opinion

Labour reform: the direct route gets the vote

It is interesting to note that the privatisation of the Port of Izmir, Turkey has been temporarily suspended after a legal challenge by a union that it is contrary to the public interest. The thought springs to mind as to why government hadn’t got this aspect covered before the launch of the privatisation process and the subsequent award of the concession to Hutchison Port Holdings and its partners EIB and Global Investment Holding.

But this brings us back to the old horse and cart discussion i.e. what comes first? Is it the job of government to sort out labour before a privatisation or is it better done under the new private sector culture when it takes over control?

Well let’s not sit on the fence – I would say every time it is better if government gets to grips with the problem as a prelude to privatisation rather than leave it to somebody else to clear up what is inevitably a mess. Where this has been done – the UK for example – new private sector operations have advanced at a quicker pace with commensurate benefits to the economy as a whole. Where it has not been done or really just been done in principle but not followed through – for instance Spain and Italy respectively – then problems keep occurring and scaling up to new levels.

There are diverse day-to-day problems relating to operational efficiency and when it comes to the time to invest in new capacity, the investment equation becomes more and more complex largely due to the high cost of labour. Note in this respect the new Hutchison terminal in Barcelona which will feature a high degree of automation intended not just to deliver a premier performance but reduce labour cost.

The lesson is clear: if you drive round labour issues then, as the colloquial saying in the UK goes, they will almost inevitably come back and “bite you on the bum". Against this background then it will be interesting to see what occurs with the current round of privatisations in the eastern Mediterranean – not only Turkey but Greece where the unions have a reputation for being militant. Sadly, it looks as though it is the operators that will be left on the front line with this challenge while governments take the money and … (you guessed it)!

Images for this article - click to enlarge

Get in early to smooth labour concerns pre-privatisation

Unless otherwise stated, all images copyright © Mercator Media 2008. This does not exclude the owner's assertion of copyright over the material.

Motorship