Dashboard: Equipment statistics are more visible through improved monitoring technologies
Alex Hughes finds out if improved remote monitoring tools are making redundancy redundant
As technology has advanced, port terminal equipment manufacturers have been able to convince their clients that quay cranes and yard machinery benefit tremendously from the incorporation of varying degrees of redundancy. They do so arguing that if vital parts and components fails, there is always back-up in place to ensure that the particular handling equipment can continue to function.
Other manufacturers have taken a different route entirely, suggesting that only by investing in expensive top-end engineering can they be sure that their gantry crane or pneumatic unloader will not break down when it can least afford to.
The most worrying aspect of either approach is that a premium has to be charged. Redundancy equals duplication of equipment or systems, while opting for top-of-the-range components automatically means higher capital investment.
Yet these two differing approaches may well have had their day.
The dramatic fall in price of technology suggests that a third approach is now possible: remove high levels of redundancy and replace them instead with remote monitoring equipment that has the ability to detect anomalies that suggest a problem is developing.
Such an approach is already becoming commonplace in many industries and, crucially, could bring down equipment prices by taking away redundant redundancy.
CHS Engineering Services Ltd, for example, is currently monitoring the performance of quay cranes at DP World’s London Gateway terminal on the River Thames. Chief operating officer Giles Price notes that this involves fixing one of the company’s mobile-phone sized Foundations Connect Hubs to the crane and connecting that to a power supply. An array of sensors is then attached to this device, which monitors three variables: temperature, vibration and humidity. Using a SIM card embedded within the hub, information is sent directly to the Foundations Connect cloud platform. This is analysed in real time and the results made available live to the client online and via SMS, Email and status dashboards.
In the past, this type of activity was done manually on site, but by turning to using cloud-based technology, CHS can cut costs by up to 40%.
According to Mr Price: “By constantly checking vibration, temperature and humidity, CHS is looking to both spot trends and, crucially, any changes compared to historical data. A drop in temperature, a rise in humidity, or increased vibration, might indicate that components in a machine are failing, or that the ambient conditions around the system are causing problems and that this could have a negative operational impact,” he says.
However, first thresholds have to be set. If these are breached, an alarm is sent to the client. If no action is then taken to bring the variable back into a normal range, a second alarm is sent.
“The technology for doing this type of monitoring existed ten years ago, although was prohibitively priced. Prices have subsequently fallen and now any equipment operator can make a financial case for adopting such monitoring. At CHS, we believe that this will enable any crane operator to generate a return on investment within a year,” says Mr Price.
Both temperature and humidity sensors are now extremely affordable, he adds, while even vibration sensors can no longer be regarded as prohibitively expensive.
“Depending on what is being monitored, we might need just one or two sensors, or eight or nine if it is a more complicated item,” he says.
Asked how customers can save money, he says that CHS monitoring equipment has already prevented major bearing failures. Added to which, comparing current performance against historical data can rapidly identify anomalies.
“If we know how a bearing normally behaves, we can spot, for example, additional vibration building up around it, perhaps suggesting that something is amiss and requires investigation,” he says.
Significantly, CHS can build up a knowledge bank of different types of equipment – perhaps similar bearings provided by a different supplier – and determine which performs best in various quay crane applications. This means the company can help customers plan maintenance strategies and decide when to choose best operational downtime.
“By being able to provide better independent information on performance and reliability of equipment could eventually result in less redundancy having to be built into equipment, since a lot of redundancy is there to cope with unpredicted failures. Through better monitoring, significant capital benefits can accrue while also improving the lifecycle of equipment. So, instead of providing 10%-20% redundancy, manufacturers might feel happier with just 5%,” says Mr Price.
He also stresses that, being an independent provider of monitoring equipment, crane operators know that information on crane performance is secure when passing through the CHS IoT powered system.
“We have no client versus supplier confidentiality issues. There is no conflict of interest,” he stresses.
In respect of how much redundancy cranes need to ensure that they do not often fail in operation, Thomas Jähnig, Liebherr’s marketing manager for maritime cranes, notes that company focus has always been on maintaining high levels of availability, which results in both reduced acquisition cost and mantainance costs. “Redundancy does not increase either availability or safety, since the crane would be heavier and more expensive. Nevertheless, we do incorporate redundancy systems, but this is to bring our cranes in line with current legislation, above all where safety systems are concerned,” he says.
As to how much redundancy adds to the overall cost of units, Mr Jähnig says that this is harder to define, because it very much depends on the system development process. “In terms of additional weight that redundancy adds to the crane, this is also hard to define for exactly the same reasons,” he says.
Rather than incorporate high levels of redundancy, Liebherr has instead developed its own fleet management monitoring system, called LiDAT. As well as being able to position quay cranes, it also helps in operations, monitors fuel consumption and schedules service intervals.
Data is updated several times a day and can be called up in a browser via GPRS or using a data carrier. This allows individual cranes to be located and some assigned either time or movement limitations in respect of use.
According to Mr Jähnig, this helps optimise use of cranes on the quay at all times, especially in respect of scheduled maintenance interventions, which can be better planned to minimise downtime and hence save costs as well as increasing availability of units.
The additional "Teleservice" package offered by Liebherr allows the company’s service staff to login to the controls of cranes from any location and rectify malfunctions or potential faults.
Asked whether existing cranes can be retrofitted with LiDAT, Mr Jähnig says that it can be used on any CAN Bus-equipped Liebherr units, which effectively means any units built within the past two decades. “However, we offer LiDAT as an option and not all customers decide to install it on their machines,” he says.
REMOTE MONITORING FINDS PAIN POINTS
Given that remote monitoring technology is getting better by the day, Port Strategy asked Liebherr's Thomas Jähnig whether this would reduce the need for redundancy since terminals would be able to identify when a part or component is acting strangely and replace it before it fails.
He responded by pointing out that Liebherr's fleet management monitoring system LiDAT is already able to identify possible problems on components before they happen, but forecasting failure is more difficult, because the system tracks real time loading parameters and it is only possible to derive predictions from that data. The main advantage for the customer is that they are able to track current efficiency while cargo is being handled and also optimise potential use, he says. The cost of the GSM/GPS-based LIDU Box monitoring, he adds, is negligible.
If improved remote monitoring means redundancy is reduced, this won’t necessarily lead to either cheaper or lighter cranes, he says, since reduced redundancy will have little impact on overall crane weight. Nor will quay loadings be reduced. “It’s difficult to define how much money an operator can save by increasing remote monitoring of parts and components on a crane, since this depends on many parameters, including exactly how the machine is used,” he says.
However, cost savings accrue because of several factors: reduced downtime, because problems can be located and analysed very fast; reduced downtimes because of prognoses via tracked machine history; and reductions in travel and maintenance cost, since it's possible to clarify possible problems from a distance.
Links to related companies and recent articles ...
- Operational insight
- Liebherr to supply Grangemouth STS crane
- Saqr orders cranes for bulk operation
- Liebherr unveils latest material handlers
- Liebherr launches smartApp
- LIEBHERR UNVEILS ITS NEW MACHINE
- Flexible friends
- CRANE WARS
- Take a load off
- MHC GAINS RECOGNITION IN BULK SECTOR
- Barometer for all Trades
- Liebherr orders tick over
- Synchronised lifting with safety
- Boost for Gdansk
- Dublin and Algeria plan on Liebherr
- Liverpool crane and straddle overhaull
- Productivity and economy from Liebherr
- Trailer positioning system for New York
- La Spezia's loss, Durban's gain
- Factory opens and..
- SUPER CRANE
- Liebherr post-panamaxes in demand
- Liebherr chalks them up
- Liebherr orders for Jeddah and Barcelona
- Second-hand still a niche market
- Testing the outer limits
- Liebherr fixes sights on Indian subcontinent
- Grangemouth's great aims
- Hub potential yet to be realised
- Liebherr gets in ahead of schedule
- Liebherr's new mobile harbour crane range
- Liebherr's Olympics torch
- Middle East megamax
- Wind and quake-proof STS for Russia
- Liebherr adds to ABP base
- Liebherr wins repeat Jeddah order
- New cranes for CentrePort Wellington
- AN ALTERNATIVE SOLUTION
- Liebherr's Turkish Delight
- ..Bega signs-up
- . . . and operators add equipment
- LIEBHERR UPS KHORFAKKAN RTGS
- Cerescorp opts for Liebherr cranes in Montreal
- REACHSTACKERS HEAD EAST
- Demand soars as customers meet bulk commitments
- SYRIA SIGNS FOR LIEBHERR
- Liebherr unveils heavyweight MHC
- Liebherr awarded Moroccan contract
- Liebherr double for Turkey
- Liebherr secures Russian STS order
- Liebherr wins Russian RTG order
- Liebherr secures RMG and STS orders
- Argentinean Liebherr cranes order
- Liebherr wins Tauranga order
- Megamax order for Liebherr
- Port of Liverpool extends carrier fleet
- In perfect harmony
- Performance guaranteed
- Still in the running
- BCT handles windfarm components
- Tandem lift splits manufacturers
- Going mobile
- Liebherr drives Indian sales
- Large Liebherr order for Kuwait
- Liebherr stays on track
- Liebherr continues Yemen relationship
- Messy play
- Liebherr nets DPW Egypt contract
- Tackling tool expense
- Liebherr cranes in demand
- Taking it neat - or home brew?
- Big is beautiful
- Liebherr Container Cranes
- Western stronghold
- Liebherr grows its Montreal family
- Moving on up
- Liebherr taps Middle East growth
- Liebherr targets European orders
- A matter of control
- Liebherr's UK family grows
- Liebherr wins Ngqura contract
- Cranes go east
- Liebherr celebrates Russian first
- Size matters
- Liebherr NZ return
- BCT celebrates first heavy load
- Driven by efficiency
- New mobile cranes for ICTSI Syria
- Lower lead time a boon for users
- Set adrift
- Scratch the surface
- Craning for a better view
- Capacity boost continues at Cape Town
- Montreal terminals increase handling power
- Liebherr's successful year
- LIEBHERR TO SUPPLY RTGS TO ABP
- Odessa celebrates leap in throughput
- Dredging flexibility earmarked for the emerald isle
- Japan to finance Mombasa box terminal
- Buenaventura bubble
- Maersk marks TICT first
- Liebherr's reachstacker rationale
- Altamira investment
- Hull and Goole upwardly mobile
- ARE YOU SITTING COMFORTABLY?
- ONE CAREFUL OWNER FULL SERVICE HISTORY. . .
- APMT selects Navis operating system
- Liebherr and Grup TCB crane design
- Cranes to double Felixstowe rail capacity
- Reach stackers: six big questions
- RMG Middle East first for LCC
- Crane frenzy
- Do your homework
- First Liebherr cranes to Peru
- Lyttelton invests in container terminal
- Liebherr order intake
- Manila order for LCC
- Liebherr wins European orders
- Sennebogen ‘world first’ for Turkey
- Keeping the pace
- Strengthening operations with a green theme
- Cargotec collects refurbishment projects
- Stop the rot
- Liebherr orders flood in
- Liebherr takes Chilean order
- Green RTG orders
- Liebherr cranes boost Belgian activity
- Crane of thought
- Unique articulated STS design passes tests
- Liebherr nets repeat orders
- Brighter bulk handling
- Safety first
- Operational insight
- P&O Ports wins Sète contract
- DP World advises on Indonesia’s development
- Shaping partnerships to reduce risk of port investments
- DP World under union microscope
- Trump’s trade agenda
- Crane collapse at Jebel Ali
- DP World to invest USD$1bn in India
- Higher bids for Thessaloniki share
- DP World enjoys 29.9% profit growth
- DPW Australia price hikes ‘could have been higher’
- DP World invests in greener future
- DP World wins Djibouti dispute
- DPW in final three for Townsville bid
- Trump’s talk ‘just a phase’, says DPW
- DP World looks to Tesla technology
- DP World invited to join El Pilar project
- DP World UAE volumes 'stabilise'
- Ecuadorian port investment planned for 2017
- DP World chief sees potential for growth in India
- DP World pairs up with global investment partner
- DP World seeks BA terminal renewals
- DPW still committed to Tasmanian terminal
- DP World Southampton strengthens fleet
- Global operators spearhead environmental initiative
- DP World invests in Australian terminals
- DP World wins 30-year concession
- DPW Australia opens inland hub
- DP World slows down Jebel Ali expansion
- A revolutionary new way of moving boxes
- DP World dismisses Melbourne claims
- DP World wins Rodney Container Terminal tender
- DP World to explore opportunities in Taiwan
- Green certification for DP World
- All change for Buenos Aires
- Ecuador showcases port potential
- DP World Australia boasts of 100% VGM accuracy
- DP World lists $1.2bn Sukuk
- Posorja to become major industrial zone
- Contecon's Posorja legal challenge rejected
- Contecon files claim against DPW
- DP World wins Ecuador concession
- DP World orders 10 Kalmar hybrid strads
- Alliances, uncertainties and opportunities
- DP World launches MENA education programme
- DP World and Georgia discuss economic cooperation
- Screen time
- Ready or not
- Do your homework
- High risk, high reward?
- Shipping industry signs up to pilot XVELA platform
- Strong financial results for DP World
- DP World in Tasmanian deal
- Green initiative ends on a high note
- DP World set to slash costs
- DP World's Callao terminal a year ahead of schedule
- DPW still committed to London Gateway
- No bail out for DP World
- Vietnam's SPCT plans go deep
- Botany reform threat hangs heavy
- DP World detects market stabilisation
- Southampton crane collapse concerns
- Equatorial Guinea capacity boost
- DP World remains profitable
- DP World unfazed by economic downturn
- Strike greets DP World handover at Aden
- Ports free of Dubai woes - almost
- Port Trust could manage vacated Kochi box terminal
- DP World stake 'not for sale'
- Waiting times to fall at Algiers
- DPW nets ISO first
- DP World boosts Indian investment
- Thames dredging poised to start
- DP World linked to London IPO
- Port operators reveal carbon stats to tackle climate change
- DP World goes all-electric in Sydney
- DP World proposes share consolidation
- DP World announce 10% growth
- DP World pumps up UAE capacity
- New terminal inauguration in Senegal
- Sokhna strike strife for DP World
- London Gateway ‘biggest threat’ to Felixstowe
- Aden to renegotiate DP World concession?
- DP World handles record 54.7m teu
- Strikes end at Sokhna
- Jebel Ali set to get rail link
- DPW ups Melbourne straddle fleet
- DPW Adelaide sale result of right exercise
- Yemen to end DP World's Aden tenure
- TEN-T grant for Maasvlakte 2 operator
- Tratos wins Jebel Ali contract
- Aden to end agreement with DP World
- DP World to sell Antwerp break bulk stake
- DPW supplies cranes for Jebel Ali port
- DPW lone bidder for new JNTP terminal
- Sokhna stand-off hits DP World operations
- Work resumes at Sokhna
- DP World launches bio-straddle trial
- DP World bags new terminal at JN Port
- DP World to restructure Indian investment
- DP World rides the world’s markets
- Everything in its place
- DP World investment granted approval
- DP World throughput up in 2012
- Giant cranes for DP World’s London Gateway
- DP World see profits rise in 2012
- Quick payback offers tracking incentive
- Brisbane battleground for DPW
- A balancing act
- DP World development at Kazakhstan
- DP World performance dip
- DP World entrepreneurship programme
- DP World sues Australian unions
- DP World asset management
- Come together
- Port unions target DP World
- China's chrysalis
- Jebel Ali makes the switch
- DP World blighted by global union action
- Growing pains
- London Gateway open for business
- Middle East overcapacity talk dismissed
- Kalmar container handlers for DP World
- A soft target
- Born leaders
- Politics of ports
- Australian box productivity reform success
- DP World clings on to throughput growth
- The London Gateway experience
- DP World: Success is about being selective
- DP World unveils new British berth
- Terminals prepare for equipment influx
- M&S pulls out of London Gateway
- Investments and arrivals
- SICK helps launch “trouble-free” operations
- DP World Australia pioneers box weighing fee
- DP World dismissed by Djibouti
- India's political push
- DP World calls off Fremantle lock out
- DP World and HPH go ‘green’
- DP World faces trouble down under
- Outrage at DPW Brisbane failings
- DP World to exit London Stock Exchange
- DP World reports record growth
- Kalmar automates London Gateway
- DP World guns for 100m teu by 2020
- MoUs all the rage
- DP World adds to Canada portfolio
- Kalmar ASCs for DP World Brisbane
- Melbourne fee freeze only part of the solution
- Kalmar gives DPW Antwerp a little lift
- Jebel Ali comes top for productivity
- Permanent home for Pentalver
- Melbourne dispute canned by rent agreement
- Port industry leaders ‘go green’
- DP World looks to Iran
- Ambition or extravagance?
- DP World buys remaining Southampton terminal stake
- Union targets DP World drugs policy