Collaboration not confrontation?

COMMENT: Around the world port labour reforms are in train. There are not many locations where such reforms are undertaken on a proactive basis; it usually involves legislative change and grinding out a solution between employers and unions often with some sort of mediation in-between. As is now the case in Spain, writes Mike Mundy.

It is oh-so-predictable that in the case of the vast majority of port unions facing industry reforms that their first reaction is to adopt a confrontational stance. Some might argue it is natural but so too is the necessity of introducing new labour arrangements to keep pace with modern logistic system requirements and to promote competitiveness overall. On the same basis, this is why the steam engine is no longer in vogue and gas is no longer used as a sedation method in tooth extraction - modernisation!


Achieving the widespread introduction of port labour reforms is, however, invariably comparable on the pain scale to extracting teeth without anaesthetic. But does it need to be?


In an era when union membership generally is in decline, there are more legal constraints on unions, and market factors such as the advent of globalisation and the rise of competition outside the immediate local environment is there not a big incentive on the part of unions to take a proactive, collaborative approach to port reforms as opposed to a confrontational one? The tin mines in Cornwall did not last forever, coal mining in the UK is defunct, the US is no longer a source of cotton production and manufacturing, and so on. Change is inevitable so why not embrace it and aim to play a positive part in protecting member interests via this route?


In many other industry sectors, there are numerous examples of positive collaboration between unions and employers on a proactive basis which has helped to secure employment and boost earnings potential. A few simple examples are: workplace learning and development; joint Learning Committees to facilitate the introduction of new technology; and generally promoting win:win scenarios through positive collaboration between HR staff and union representatives.


Time for collaboration not confrontation.



Successful participation and presentation at exhibition in Beira, Mozambique

The exhibition series ‘Intermodal Africa’ organized by Transport Events is always a good possibility... Read more

Protectors of Esbjerg's new East Port quay

The German based Headquarters of ShibataFenderTeam recently completed an order for the Port of Esbje... Read more

Aquaplot joins Technology Transfer Programme of European Space Agency

Start-up for ocean route planning enters ESA’s Business Incubation Centre (BIC) Read more

AMRO Increases Scope To Cover The GCC Region

AMRO, a specialist marine equipment and services provider, is proud to announce that they will now c... Read more


Ninth Consecutive “Excellent” Coast Guard Security Assessment Awarded to Port of Baltimore Read more

Being part of the most important infrastructure project in Costa Rica

In 2017, the US office of ShibataFenderTeam delivered 55 nos. CSS 1450 Cell Fender Systems (G2.0), 8... Read more

View all