Tidying up inter-terminal connections

The issue of ITTs is increasingly relevant for all ports with competing terminal operators and onward feeder or intermodal connections. Credit: Huskyherz/Pixabay/CC0 The issue of ITTs is increasingly relevant for all ports with competing terminal operators and onward feeder or intermodal connections. Credit: Huskyherz/Pixabay/CC0
Industry Database

COMMENT: A study on better co-operation between terminals in Hong Kong by Hong Kong’s Hang Seng Management College has rightfully received industry attention of late, writes Peter de Langen.

The study focuses on inter-terminal transfers (ITTs) between the five terminal operating companies in Hong Kong. The terminals charge for these ITTs, thus adding costs to already-high terminal rates in comparison with competing ports.

Inter-terminal moves arise when a container arrives at, for example, terminal A, but needs to be moved to terminal B for the onward (feeder) transport. Given the rise of consortia and the increase in ship sizes, the issue of ITTs is increasingly relevant for all ports with competing terminal operators and onward feeder or intermodal connections. The study mentions that around 15% of total volume is transferred between terminals.

With the use of simulation, the study found that the number of ITTs can be significantly reduced (around 50%) if the different terminals are managed as one facility, so facilities such as quays and cranes are shared. Competing ports such as Singapore and Shanghai are already managed as one facility as they are operated by one operator.

However, the suggestion of joint planning of ships across facilities of competing terminal operators is problematic. There are clear advantages from an operations perspective, but such an initiative is hard to reconcile with competition between terminal operators. Under the suggested ‘centralised planning’ it is hard to see how the terminals could compete effectively on price and service levels, and this competition also brings clear benefits to Hong Kong’s port.

In contrast with the Hong Kong study, in my view the most pragmatic starting point is to focus on solutions that leave the competitive dynamics between terminal operators intact, and optimise the efficiency and sustainability of ITT movements.

A collective ‘container exchange service’ to optimise ITT movements could combine competition between the terminal operators for handling ships with collective efficiency for ITT movements. Given the more than 2,000 daily ITT moves reported in the study and the close proximity of Hong Kong’s terminals, such a container exchange service may not need to rely on individual trucks as is currently the case. Alternatively, transport by barge or truck platoons may also be (or become) relevant options.

In conclusion, for ports with intra-port competition, ITT is an increasingly relevant issue. A collaborative process to develop one port-wide ITT service may be the pragmatic approach. It may be a less bold move than sharing all terminal assets but would still be a major step forward compared with the current uncoordinated ITT moves. This applies not just in Hong Kong but also to most, if not all, ports with competing terminal operators.

LATEST PRESS RELEASES

Custom designed vehicle loading bay supports growth and efficiency

Fabric building specialist Rubb has created a new hub for vehicle loading operations for Walkers Tra... Read more

SHOREHAM PORT UNVEILS NEW VISITOR CENTRE FOR HIRE

There are exciting times ahead for Shoreham Port in 2019, as it expands its bank of commercial prope... Read more

Fender specialists share know-how at seminars in Indonesia

December was a true seminar month for our ShibataFenderTeam. Together with our Indonesian agent, PT ... Read more

Important concession for Jan De Nul in Bangladesh

Jan De Nul enters into concession agreement with the Government of Bangladesh for the dredging of Pa... Read more

ShibataFenderTeam offers Berthing Energy Calculation Tool

Calculating the berthing energy of vessels is the first and most important step in the fender design... Read more

New digital technology project that aims to work with North East ports

A NEW programme that aims to pilot smart digital initiatives to boost trade and foster economic grow... Read more

View all